News from the Land of Milk and Honey

I had the good fortune to attend a conference on Precision Medicine and Ageing today. This brought some of the leading scientists from the UK and Israel together, as part of the British Council’s Britain Israel Science and Innovation Network. The day included speakers talking about the latest breakthroughs in genomics, neuroscience, cellular biology and many other fields of scientific endeavour and how they relate to the biology of ageing (in health as well as disease) and how these breakthroughs are bringing us closer to the ‘promised land’ of Personalised, or Precision medicine.

The talk that I found the most interesting came from Dr Maya Leventer-Roberts, from the Clalit Research Institute. This is not a university department, but the in-house research arm of the largest of Israels four health providers. They have an unparallelled treasure-trove of health data. She explained that all Israeli citizens belong to one of these four organisations who provide all aspects of care: GP, pharmacy, testing laboratories, hospitals – you name it. What’s more, very few people change providers, so they have a well-coded database of people’s wellness, illness and health behaviour at all stages of life.

I have since found a paper from last year which uses some of their data to examine a relatively neglected aspect of Parkinson’s – depression. Unfortunatley a huge proportion of people with Parkinson’s struggle with depression. We also know that late onset depression is a risk factor for Parkinson’s. 

In this study, they looked at mortality rates in Parkinson’s and the association with how adherent people were with antidepressents. They analysed the data of 10,000 people with a diagnosis of Parkinson’s as well as at least one prescription of an antidepressant. They then categorised people into how frequently they tookthe antidepressants by comparing their prescriptions from the doctor with the number of purchases of antidepressants from the pharmacies. Finally they looked at death by any cause over the 4 year study period.

They found that the people who had Parkinson’s and depression who took their antidepressants the least were 43% more likely to die within the 4 year period, compared to those who took it the most regularly. The increased mortality was exacerbated by having an increasing number of other medical problems.

I must stress the old adage: association does not equal causation. This kind of retrospective observational study cannot provethat one thing causes another. However, it is an important reminder that depression is an important aspect of Parkinson’s, and that poorly managed depression is associated with increased mortality. It also reminds me that older people, with Parkinson’s, depression and perhaps four or five other medical conditions may be on 15-20 or more tablets a day. What can I do as a clinician to help them remember what each is for, and why each is important to take? What can we do as a society to help people with depression with both drug and non-drug treatment options? How can we better prepare ourselves, individually and societally, for ageing and the only true inevitability of life?

RNR

Shoval G, Stubbs B, Balicer RD, Feldman B, Hoshen M, Zalsman G, et al. 

Low adherence to antidepressants is associated with increased mortality in Parkinson disease patients. 

Parkinsonism Relat Disord. 2017 Oct;43:92–6.

INTRODUCTION:The purpose of this study was to evaluate the relationship between adherence to antidepressants (AD) and all-cause mortality in a population-based cohort of patients with Parkinson's Disease (PD).

METHODS:From a database of more than 4 million people, 8553 patients with PD who purchased an AD at least once between the years 2008-2011 were retrospectively followed for all-cause mortality over 4-years. Adherence was measured as a ratio between dispensed and prescribed durations and was modeled as: non-adherence (<20%, n = 1566), poor (20%-50%, n = 1184), moderate (50%-80%, n = 1584), and good (>80%, n = 4219) adherence. Multivariable survival analyses adjusted for demographic and clinical variables including physical comorbidities known to influence mortality were conducted, however there was no adjustment for other psychiatric disorders and medications.

RESULTS:Unadjusted mortality rates were 20.4%, 25.1%, 23.4% and 25.6% in those classified as non-adherent, poor, moderate and good adherence respectively (χ2 = 18.45, p < 0.0001). The non-adherent and poor adherence groups had significantly increased adjusted mortality hazard ratios (HR) of 1.43 (CI: 1.26-1.62) and 1.26 (CI: 1.1-1.44) respectively compared to the good adherence group. Using the same model, the adjusted HR for death among males was 1.49 [95% CI: 1.36-1.62] compared to females. People with PD and Charslon's Comorbidity Index score of 3-4 (HR 1.3, P < 0.001) and 5+ (HR 1.78, P < 0.001) were more likely to die than those with 0-2 comorbidities.

CONCLUSIONS:Our findings suggest that poor adherence to AD is associated with increased all-cause mortality in people with PD. Given the high prevalence of depression and AD effectiveness, efforts to promote adherence should be prioritized in clinical practice.