PLAIN ENGLISH: Does removal of the appendix impact the risk of Parkinson's Disease?

Multiple large news organisations yesterday were reporting the results of a study showing that people who have had appendectomies (surgical removal of the appendix) have a lower chance of developing Parkinson's disease. Its a neat paper which links large amounts of data from medical databases and histology results (looking at tissue under the microscope) on a much smaller number of patients.

First they looked at the Swedish National Patient Registry, a database of 1,698,000 people followed up for 52 years, and identified anyone who had a history of an appendectomy (551,647 people). They then matched these patients to two 'control' patients who had not had appendectomies but were similar in age, sex and geographical to the original patients. They interestingly found that the chance of having Parkinson's disease was 19.3% lower in the participants with appendectomies than the 'control' participants who had not had appendectomies. They also found that the participants who had appendectomies and developed Parkinson's on average developed Parkinson's 1.6 years later than the Parkinson's patients who still had their appendix. Interestingly this effect was not observed in participants who had known genetic mutations causing their Parkinson's suggesting that if the appendix has any effect on the development of Parkinson's it is only in patients whose Parkinson's has an 'environmental' trigger or cause.

This part of the study was not novel or new and previous similar studies have been done and found no association between appendectomy and PD. In a Canadian study they actually found a higher rate of PD in patients who had appendectomies in the past 5 years. So despite the results of this study being very interesting they are not backed up by previous studies.

The novel part of this study is the histological analysis where the researchers analysed the 48 peoples appendixes under the microscope. These participants did not have PD. The appendixes were analysed under the microscope for clumps of protein which have stuck together that we call 'aggregates of α-syneuclein'. These are the key feature of PD that can be found in PD patients brains at autopsy. In other words the misfolded protein that causes PD when it is seen in the brain can be seen in young, healthy peoples appendix. These misfolded proteins were detected in both young and old people.

There are some problems with this study; first is that in large databases it is very difficult to know the accuracy of the Parkinson's diagnosis and previous studies investigating the reliability of this found only a 70.8% chance that it is reliable. They also only examined the appendix under the microscope and did not check any other tissues to compare.

This study does provide some food for thought; at the end of the paper the authors hypothesise that the appendix is the source of the misfolded protein that then spreads through the gut and up the vagus nerve to the brain thereby causing Parkinson's disease. This gut to brain model of the development of Parkinson's disease is often discussed and is a popular research topic at the moment. However the results of this study should still be taken with a pinch of salt because there are a number of large scale similar studies that precede this study that do not come to the same conclusion, that doesn't stop it being interesting though!